In 1971, Amar and Raj, his wife, took a chance on the American Dream. Amar, an engineer, accepted a job at Louisiana State University, and although Raj, a nuclear physicist from a prominent Punjabi family, was six months pregnant at the time, they boarded a plane and resettled in Baton Rouge. There, they raised a family, two boys, both of whom they gave traditional Indian names. Their oldest was named Piyush, which means “milk,” and their youngest was named Nikesh, which roughly translates as “joy.”

Although they were a world away from India and although there wasn’t a Hindu temple in their newly adopted hometown, Amar and Raj continued to practice their religion. Religious services and ceremonies were held in the homes of other Indian immigrants. They raised their children as Hindus. As often as they could, they took family vacations to India. At least once a week, they would read passages from the Vedas to their boys.

Today, Amar and Raj still reside in Baton Rouge, and by any measure, they realized the promise of the American Dream. They own a home in a gated community, near the Baton Rouge Country Club. Amar works for one of the biggest engineering firms in the world, and Raj rose up the ranks at the Louisiana Department of Labor. Their first son went to Brown and then became a Rhodes Scholar. Their second son attended Dartmouth and then Yale Law School.


When he was four years old, Amar and Raj Jindal’s first son, Piyush, asked to be called Bobby after Bobby Brady of “The Brady Bunch.” When he was eighteen, Bobby converted to Catholicism, and as an undergrad, he wrote about his conversion experience extensively, submitting his personal essays for publication in some of the country’s most well-known Catholic journals. His parents, he claimed, were initially disappointed about his conversion; they thought he was rejecting them, his heritage, and his traditions. But eventually, they realized he was earnest; it wasn’t merely youthful rebellion. Amar and Raj accepted and respected him fully.

America, after all, was founded by immigrants who believed in religious tolerance.


This week, the Louisiana legislature is considering naming the Bible as the state’s “official book.” The bill, HB 503, already advanced out of committee. To be sure, it’s an entirely symbolic gesture, but nonetheless, the bill is certainly, defiantly unconstitutional, not that the United States Constitution matters to Louisiana lawmakers. Earlier in the session, the Louisiana Senate voted down a bill that would repeal a law requiring creationism to be taught alongside evolution in public schools, a law the Supreme Court struck down in 1987 but that, nonetheless, remains on the books. And on Tuesday, the Louisiana House rejected a bill that would revise the state’s unconstitutional anti-sodomy law to ensure it complied with the Supreme Court’s ruling in Lawrence v. Texas. Next week, the Louisiana Senate Education Committee will consider, for the fourth time, repealing the Louisiana Science Education Act, the state’s most recent unconstitutional attempt to inject new earth creationism in public school science classrooms.

Amar and Raj’s son leads a state that is now increasingly dominated by Christian dominionists, and under his watch, Louisiana lawmakers from both parties have become increasingly emboldened to codify their personal religious beliefs. Governor Jindal famously warned national Republicans that they need to stop being “the stupid party,” yet his own legislature, which is controlled by a Republican supermajority, continues to introduce and pass some of the dumbest, most blatantly unconstitutional laws in the country.

But the fault cannot be blamed entirely on Republicans. During the committee hearing on the bill to name the Bible as the state’s official book, Representative Stephen Ortego, a Democrat from Acadiana, objected, not because the bill was an affront to his constituents who practice another faith, but because the specific Bible identified by the bill was a King James Version, which was an affront to his religious beliefs as a devout Catholic. Ortego, without any sense of irony, didn’t argue that the state should recognize a more inclusive book; he argued that it should recognize a more Catholic-friendly Bible.

In many ways, the bill is designed to put Louisiana legislators in an almost impossible bind: It’s asking them to vote against the Bible.

The script needs to be flipped.

By voting to make the Bible the state’s official book, legislators are actually voting against the fundamental freedoms enshrined by the Constitution. They are voting against an America that celebrates and champions religious tolerance, inclusiveness, and diversity. Though they may not recognize it, they are voting to embrace the same type of fascist laws that motivate and inspire radical Islamic fundamentalists, laws that promote rigid theocracy.

And they are voting to make Louisiana a less welcoming, less tolerant, less promising land of opportunity for people like Amar and Raj Jindal.

6 thoughts

  1. What a load of bull-pucky…. If the liberal nut-balls can get past their hatred of all things God, they would realize the Bible is a great piece of literature. It encompasses every genre; love, hate, sex, murder, poetry, mystery, thriller, climate; you name it, it’s there. You can even find a little sci/fi in there if you know where to look.

    The Hindu family described in the article discovered right away they were free to practice their religion in the United States, just as their neighbors and eventually their son, are free to practice theirs. Naming the Bible the state book shouldn’t be considered a religious act. The Bible is the best-selling book in the world, read by billions of people and applied to every facet of life, not just religion. You can’t say that about the guiding books of the world’s major religions; i.e. Hindu, Muslim, etc.. Even the LDS have their own book, strictly based on their religious idiom, and Jehovah Witnesses print their own magazine and push it door-to-door, but no one lambasts them about it. If a person doesn’t want to believe in God, that’s their choice. I don’t have a problem believing in God but religion scares me, especially when they declare their viewpoint is the only path to God or righteousness.

    So my opinion is, Louisiana is perfectly within their rights to name the Bible their state book, and they should do so without giving in to the foolish rantings of liberals or religious separatists that fear their own inner shortcomings. If naming a book scares them that much, let them move to the Middle East where they don’t have a choice. They’ll be back soon.

    1. I didn’t think it was necessary to explain why, exactly, the bill to name the Bible as the “official book” is unconstitutional, but apparently, I should have. The First Amendment of the United States Constitution expressly prohibits Congress from passing laws “respecting the establishment of religion.” And so does the Louisiana State Constitution. “No law shall be enacted respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” La. Const. art. I, § 8.

      Mr. Laughter, I respect your belief that the Bible is an amazing “sci-fi” (your words) thriller filled with wisdom and truth, but it’s, definitively, a religious text. I think it is notable and troubling, however, that you seem to be defending this effort by way of disparaging the religious traditions and the sacred texts of people who do not share your own beliefs.

      Passing a law that would make the Bible the “official state book” is precisely and exactly what the Establishment Clause of the US Constitution and Article One Section Eight of the Louisiana State Constitution were designed to prohibit. If you prefer to live in a country that allows and encourages the state sponsorship of a particular religion, then you should take your own advice and move to the Middle East.

  2. Well said Mr. White…I feel that everyone should be allowed to believe what they want…but to have anything imposed on others is by law unconstitutional. Why don’t we just make the state book, “A Confederacy of Dunces” by John Kennedy Toole? Afterall…it was written by a Louisiana native and was awarded a Pulitzer Prize. 🙂

  3. I see a lot of interesting content on your blog. You have to spend a lot of time writing, i know how to save you a lot of time, there is a tool that creates unique, SEO friendly posts in couple of minutes, just search in google – laranita’s free
    content source

Leave a Reply to Cynthia Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s